i do love both but to be honest when you first meet dr who in the very first episode an unearthly child he was a nasty old man with no intentions of helping anyone he was there with his grand daughter until the teachers go to find her as they are concerned bout her outook on london in the dark scrap yard it was dark and intense, he was callous, harsh and no intent on telling people who he is, for its era william hartnell was to me the best dr who as he was who he was and made dr who what it is today matt does well with what he has and moffat is a brilliant script writer but sadly producers do have alot of say in what is produced if you compare his work to sherlock you can see the technical side of script writing but sadly when it came back was made more for children hence the baddies looking more i use the word kiddified to describe the sad factor as the baddies should b what they were but standards come into it and have to make do with what you have for prime tv these days.